The remains of the house at 1005 Main Street in Guthrie Center.Officials from the Iowa Division of Criminal Investigation arrive at the scene of the house fire at 1005 Main Street. Fire crews were called to 1005 Main Street at 12:30 a.m. Monday morning. By 10:30 a.m., firefighters from the Panora and Guthrie Center fire departments were still working. Fire crews were called to 1005 Main Street at 12:30 a.m. Monday morning. By 10:30 a.m., firefighters from the Panora and Guthrie Center fire departments were still working. Stuffed animals lie in a pile of rubble at the scene of a house fire on 1005 Main Street. The fire, which began early Monday morning, was fatal.

Overnight house arson kills two girls

A state fire marshal has determined the fire was intentional, but law officers are mum about the circumstances

Someone intentionally set fire to a house that killed two girls, ages 16 and 12, early Monday morning in Guthrie Center, a state fire marshal concluded after a two-day investigation.
Shakiah Cockerham, 16, and her cousin Melanie “Paige” Exline, 12, died in the fire at 1005 Main St. that was reported about 12:30 a.m., according to Mitch Mortvedt, an assistant director for the Iowa Division of Criminal Investigation.
“The Fire Marshal’s office has ruled it’s arson, making the deaths a criminal act as well,” Mortvedt said. “We are pursuing all leads.”
He declined to reveal more about the investigation, such as how they think the fire began.
Four people were asleep in the house at the time of the fire. Two people — Shirley Exline, 74, and William Long III, 54 — escaped. Exline owns the house, county records show.
Court records show Exline is the great-grandmother and legal guardian of Cockerham, and that Long is the girl’s great uncle.
“You just can’t prepare yourself for this,” said Dave Embleton, the town’s fire chief. “Pulling young children out of fires, you can’t prepare for that. I have two kids of my own, roughly the same age as those two, and that makes it a little more tough for me.”
Firefighters found one of the girls’ bodies in the morning and one that afternoon.
Exline and Long were taken to an Omaha hospital for treatment — Exline for minor injuries and Long for severe burns to his upper body. Long is still in the hospital.
“I think the adults got up and tried to get out,” Sheriff Marty Arganbright said. “I don’t know if there was an explosion because of the heat of the fire — it blew a window out — but the man and woman got out, and the two juveniles could not.
“It was such a tragic fire ... two young girls, that’s what makes it so bad.”
It was a tough day for his department, but Embleton said everyone is holding up pretty well.
“Nobody in our department has ever been through anything like this, it was a first for all of us,” he said. “I’d like to thank the community for their outpouring support. And I can’t thank Panora enough, they matched our numbers and it just says a lot about how our communities can pull together and work as one.”
Arganbright echoed the support from the community.
“I’m selfish with Guthrie County, I think we have it the best,” he said.
Whoever set the fire faces potential felony charges of first-degree arson and homicide or murder, the most serious of which is punishable by life in prison.

Contact Us

Guthrie Center Times
PO Box 217
205 State Street
Guthrie Center, IA 50115
641-332-2380

Guthrie County Vedette
PO Box 38
111 E. Main Street
Panora, IA 50216
641-755-2115

Sign Up For Breaking News

Stay informed on our latest news!

Manage my subscriptions

Subscribe to Newsletter feed